Wednesday, April 18, 2007

Sojourners and the Federal Budget

Today I got an email from Sojourners. Part of the body of the email stated:
As Americans file tax returns this week, let's consider what we are getting for our money. For every dollar we pay in federal income taxes, 36 cents goes toward past and present military spending.

So out of curiosity, I decided to check the accuracy of this information. Strait to Wikipedia I went and looked up the Federal budget. A pie chart graphic indicates that 17% of the Federal Budget for 2007 is earmarked for military spending. That would be 17 cents of every dollar goes toward current military spending. On top of that, 9% is designated for the interest on the national debt. Let's say that all debt was incurred for military spending. This would mean that 26 cents of every dollar spent is going toward military spending. Okay, so somewhere between 17 and 26 cents of every dollar spent goes to the military. Now, the wording from Sojourners is that 36 cents of every dollar collected in Federal Income Tax goes toward military spending, we then ask, how much of that dollar comes just from Federal Income Tax? Per Wikipedia again, about 56.6% of the 2.4 trillion dollar federal budget comes from individual and corporate income tax. That means that 34.2% of the Federal budget from Income Tax goes to military spending. That's pretty close to the Sojourner's figure, so I'm guessing that's how they came up with it. Interesting way to go from 17% spent on military to 34%.

But the appeal is to spend more on poverty and welfare than on the military or "war" as they put it (not the defense of our country, the defeat of terrorism, the enforcement of justice, or the many acts of mercy that the military carry out). But according to Wikipedia's numbers again, the next three categories of spending for the Federal budget are Medicare, Welfare and Medicaid. Those three together make up over one trillion dollars, or more than twice what is spent on the military. If you factor in Social Security at 589 billion dollars, the amount spent on these programs is now treble the number spent on miliatry and defense.

I'm not against spending money on programs to alleviate poverty and suffering, if these programs do indeed do this. Our Christian duty is to help the poor and suffering (though not necessarily to make the government do it for us). What is frustrating though is the rhetorical devices used by political groups like Sojourners that dramatize an issue without presenting it in it's full light. The tendentiousness of the emails and appeals I receive from Sojourners that claim not to be partisan, but have such a slant to their message, lose whatever goodness inherent in their motivations because they are mired in politicing.

Labels: , , , ,

3 Comments:

Blogger David A Booth said...

Brad,

I didn't even realize that you had started posting on your blog. I'm way behind the curve here.

This playing (lying) with statistics is just shameful. There are a few other realities at work:

1. We are at war so the amount of money currently being spent on military stuff is inflated.

2. During the Korean and Vietnam wars we were spending 10% of GDP on the military. Shrinking the percent of GDP spent on the military throughout the 90s masked the fact that entitlement spending was exploding. The cost of Social Security and Medicare is going to continue rising sharply - and we will not be able to offset this with declining defense spending. That is just the reality of the situation. It sure would be nice if someone running for President would actually address this issue.

3. Only the Federal governemnt has a defense budget. The numbers look far less dramatic when we see "defense" as a percentage of total government spending, but wait - there's more. A large percentage of work with the poor is done through charitable donations - which are not counted. I'm pretty sure that none of us has ever donated to the U.S. military.

The good news is that, over the next 20 years, we are likly going to be able to shrink defense spending as a percentage of GDP. The bad news is that this won't even come close to paying for the social programs that we have already committed to. Pretending that it will is simply dishonest.

David

2:37 PM  
Blogger David A Booth said...

In my defense (re: falling behing on your blog), there is a two year gap between these posts!

2:38 PM  
Blogger bradster said...

David, I was going to encourage you not to be too hard on yourself since my posting is pretty erratic. I need to get more in the habit.

Thanks for your thoughts on Sojourners. Their partisan nature undermines so much of whatever good they could accomplish.

I honestly wish I could completely understand pacifism. When having dinner one night with my in-laws - committed pacifists - I said in a very non-argumentative, just-wanting-to-understand sort of way that I couldn't see how I could adopt a pacifist stance when someone breaks into my home and willing to do harm to my family. I would do anything, literally, to protect them. I really was hoping for a response from them, something to help me understand how they would look at that situation which to me represents the logical end to the position. But there was none. I really wasn't trying to pick a fight, so to speak. Because to me, this extends out to the national level as well. I would hate to have to do anything violent to protect my family, but I would; just as I would and do hate to have to do anything violent to protect my country, but I would.

So, to me, to have to accept the pacifist position one has to put what I believe God has innately provided us for our protection and self-preservation into some strange place logically which then outwardly distorts the kind of thinking that goes into the Sojourners criticism of the Fed. Budget. And if you disagree (with them), you're a war-mongering hawk bent on the bloodshed of innocent life.

9:07 AM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home